Online ordering powered by Seamless
81 THIRD AVENUE, (3rd Ave. between E. 11th St. & E. 12th St.)(212) 353-9933
Minimum order of $10.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Everything Bagels Cafe is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $10.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 30 - 45 min (more info)
Print this menu
Served all day.
Available daily until 3pm.
Made fresh daily. Call for daily specials. Served with a buttered bagel of your choice.
Sandwich or 1/4 pound.
Panini, ciabatta, baguette or wrap. Regular, whole wheat or sun-dried tomato.
Sandwiches served on a bagel or a bialy.
Baked on premises daily.
We grind our coffee beans fresh every day.
Bagels okay. Service unreliable.
They cancelled my weekly Monday morning office order one day out of the blue. When I called to ask what happened, "It's too far. We don't have anyone available to deliver. Thanks, bye." You just lost a customer and gained this lukewarm review.
Switched to Bagel Boss and it turns out, everyone likes their bagel better anyway!!
Posted 2 months ago by Nora W.
Worst experience ever. I ordered the food took extremely long to get here and ended up being a wrong order. The people that I spoke to over the phone have no idea of what to do. Never ever ordering from here again.
Posted 2 months ago by Juan C.
Terrible delivery service. They never get an order correct, and even after calling multiple times they can't seem to understand why it's a problem. EXTREMELY RUDE phone person.
Posted 3 months ago by Geordon N.
How do you deliver food and not bring half the damn order??? And then when I called them, the guy started yelling at me?? Seriously??? This place sucks!!!
Posted 6 months ago by chrisinda w.
DON'T EVER ORDER FROM HERE! They're very unreliable, not responsive to customers and forget about your order. After 1.5hrs of waiting, I called them, said it was on its way....after 2hrs, called again, they said it never went out because they didn't have one thing I ordered and couldn't find my number...and all of their deliver men arrived to work drunk so they didn't have an help. Not my problem, dude! Find a better bagel place than this one! There are plenty.
Posted 8 months ago by Elyse E.
It's been 2 HOURS since I ordered my food and it still isn't here. Not only that but their phone is off the hook so it's been busy for the past hour I've been calling. AN ABSOLUTE DISGRACE OF CUSTOMER SERVICE. Completely unacceptable. Did I mention I live across the street?
Posted 8 months ago by Alexandra W.
Took almost 2 hours to receive order and I like 5 minutes away. I should just walk there myself next time.
Posted 8 months ago by Hillary W.
Got my food 3 hours after I ordered on Seamless.
Posted 8 months ago by Anna P.
Do NOT order from here! We ordered 2 bagel sandwiches TWO hours ago. It said it would take 30-45 minutes and after calling twice, they said both times, very rudely, that the guy had already left and it would be here soon. When that never happened I called back to cancel since it is almost lunch time and the man was so awful he just said 'call seamless' and hung up on me. Really great customer service! Meanwhile I've been on hold waiting for someone to answer at seamless for 20 minutes. Horrible service! Never again
Posted 8 months ago by jordan w.
Very friendly when I called to let them know they forgot to include homefries/bagel with my order. Made the correction quickly.
Posted 9 months ago by Natalie V.
Horrible. Waited 2 hours for a small order that never arrived. Staff is exceedingly unhelpful and hung up on me every time I called. Do not order from them!!
Posted 10 months ago by Liz M.
Zero stars. It's been 90 minutes and still no sign of my food. I'm calling Seamless to cancel the order and I'll send it back if they do show up. Will not order again.
Posted 10 months ago by Vijesh G.
Just bad. They call you and try to renegotiate the prices.
Posted 10 months ago by Christof B.
Don't eat the pizza, the bagels are delicious
Posted a year ago by stephanie p.
I used to order from this place all of the time and was a long time customer. A while back I called one morning because there seamless was down and explained who I was and asked if I could make an order the man hung up on me. Then I called back thinking maybe it was a mistake, nope he just hung up. He even admitted it and asked me to call back in 20 minutes as they were very busy. BS! You can take customer treatment and loyalty and shove it up your you know where! Don't ever eat here and tell your friends to avoid it as well!
Posted a year ago by Tara N.
Posted a year ago by Michelle D.
My whitefish salad "platter" was a small blob of whitefish with a solitary lettuce leaf and one anemic slice of tomato. They left out the coleslaw entirely. The hot knish I ordered was packed on top of the black and white cookie, and by the time they delivered, the icing had all melted off into a slimy mess at the bottom of the bag. The "freshly griddled" french toast that was supposed to be 4 slices, according to the menu description, was actually 3 thin slices of rubbery white bread with a sprinkling of powdered sugar. The very basic requests in the write-in boxes, for things like essential condiments, were completely ignored. First and last time customer.
Posted a year ago by Evelyn D.
A very bad experience. I waited more than an hour for a small, simple order that was supposed to arrive in thirty to forty-five minutes. I live only a couple blocks away. When I pointed out to the delivery guy that the order had taken over an hour to get here, he shrugged, didn't even say sorry. Finally, the food was bad. The smoothie I ordered was actually undrinkable: It hadn't been blended enough. This is the worst experience I've had through Seamless. Do not go to this restaurant.
Posted a year ago by Stuart W.
a bagel, a muffin and a coffee took over 90 mins to deliver. Seamless has this place listed as 30-45 mins for delivery. Terrible place, would not order from again.
Posted a year ago by Chad R.
DON'T order from this place. They took 1:45 minutes to deliver a bagel and juice. If you want to wait that long for your breakfast, go for it. However, there are way too many bagel places in the city to be subjected to this crap. The food isn't that good anyways.
Posted a year ago by shawn m.
Food was cold. Packaging awful. Everything in the bag was sticky and took about an hour and a half to arrive. :(
Posted a year ago by Meredith M.
Awful. its been an HOUR AND A HALF and they keep telling me my 4 bagels are on the way. Unless you like cold gross food that takes forever I would not order from here.
Posted a year ago by KRISTI P.
Again, took another + hour to deliver, will not call again
Posted a year ago by Violeta F.
I called after 1.5 hours (delivery time was estimated 30 - 45 minutes) and was received rudely on the phone with excuses saying it had been a very busy morning and my delivery would arrive in, "20 minutes". 1.5 MORE hours later (3 hours total) the food arrived cold and soggy. I won't be ordering from here again.
Posted a year ago by Mike S.
This took two and a half hours to get delivered. All the food was cold. Terrible experience.
Posted a year ago by Michelle C.
I have a hard time rating a restaurant if the food that was ordered never shows up and if the phone is always busy or when it rings, no one picks up when calling to check up on delivery time.
Posted a year ago by Stephen P.
The food came quickly and was good. The only down side was that they ran out of veg soup but they called me immediately and it was easy to get my money back. Overall a good experience.
Posted a year ago by Molly E.
Really good bagels. Large assortment of cream cheeses. Amazing selection of smoothies. Make your own smoothie, even! I just wish that the store would change its delivery estimate. I live less than two blocks away, and 3--45 min became an hour and a half... tsk tsk.
Posted a year ago by Gaby C.
bagels taste awful. i ordered a simple bagel and cream cheese for delivery and they sent me chicken salad instead. awful
Posted a year ago by ashley d.
The food took over an hour to get delivered and the delivery man had a very nasty attitude. My food was cold and the order was incomplete. I will never order from this place again.
Posted a year ago by Rashri S.
Unlike other reviewers on here, my order was correct and the food was packaged well (hot and no spills) but it DID take over an hour to arrive.
But the coffee is perfectly acceptable, good bagel and delicious juice.
Posted a year ago by Adele M.
horrible customer service and slow delivery
Posted 2 years ago by William F.
If they don't have what you want, they just send something else. They don't contact you and ask what would be okay. Won't use them again.
Posted 2 years ago by Bonnie R.
I love their food! BUT the delivery is terrible. It takes forever and they always mess up my order. I ordered a coke, i got diet coke. I ordered a bagel with lox & cream cheese, I got a bagel with lox flavored cream cheese. I ordered chocolate chip cookies and got macadamia. Better idea to go there and get your order right.
Posted 2 years ago by Jessica L.
The food is not bad but they have messed up my order literally every time I've ordered from there.
Posted 2 years ago by Samir P.
Horrible! First the food took an hour, then the delivery guy gave me someone else's order so I had to wait another 30 minutes for my food, and on top of that the bagels were disgusting.
Posted 2 years ago by Abbey A.
Delivery took an extra 15 minutes. Coffee was spilled all over the bag. Bagel reminds me of a frozen lenders.
Posted 2 years ago by Rachel g.
I will never order from this place again. The last two times I have ordered from Seamless it took them well over an hour for very simple orders. I didn't get the e-mai confirmation for at least 20 minutes. This time, I called to check on the order, was put on hold multiple times, and then the guy just laughed at me and hung up when I asked why my order was taking so long. Unreal.
Posted 2 years ago by Drew M.
WORST WAIT EVER, took TWO HOURS!!!!! called multiple times and the person who answered lied and said the delivery was on its way. WHICH WAS AN HOUR OF THE TIME.
Posted 2 years ago by joseph w.
It was an -OK- egg white omelette. Green juice available
Posted 2 years ago by Frederick S.
it's been an hour and still nothing. I called 20 mins ago and they said it was on it's way! worst thing ever
Posted 2 years ago by Lisa F.
I've only ever ordered cappuccinos and bagels but they always arrive at my door faster than the expected wait and they're always delicious.
Posted 2 years ago by Brandie B.
An hour and a half to wait! Not even at peak times...
Posted 2 years ago by suzannah b.
Unfortunately, this is the only place I can find in the EV that delivers bagel sandwhiches. The food is good, but the service is horrible. Orders consistently come about 15 minutes late. Today the quote time is 30-45 minutes. It's been an hour and I have yet to receive my order. Once I ordered and there was no one to deliver the order. It's very frustrating.
Posted 2 years ago by elisha c.
I order from everything bagels about once a week. Granted, I only ever order bagels and coffee/juice, but my orders are always correct and I usually get them faster than the delivery estimate.
Posted 2 years ago by John M.
HORRIBLE customer service! I ordered a turkey sandwich on a bagel with lettuce, cucumber, onion, and cheddar cheese. It arrived with just turkey and cheese. I called and they said because I hadn't paid for the lettuce they couldn't add it. Not only is there no option to pay for lettuce or cucumber, but I have ordered from them MULTIPLE times doing with just adding lettuce, tomato etc in the instructions box and have never had a problem. Also, had they just called me I would've happily told them to charge me extra, or if not possible, to just cancel my order. They did not offer any apology or any ways to remedy the situation. Will not order from here again.
Posted 2 years ago by Cori B.
THE WORST. Live 3 blocks away and took an hour 15 to deliver 2 bagels. Unless you have all day to wait for your food. Skip this place. There are WAY too many bagel places in this city to ever order from here again.
Posted 3 years ago by Lauren F.
this would get a four star if i didn't order it the second time.... the bagels are great. the problem is the fruit salad and juices. the fruit salad came mushed and smelled funky, some tasted like fish, it was GROSS. i tried four pieces n spit out all of them. the juice tasted fine but it came horizontal (so did the fruit salad), it was leaking everywhere when i take it outta the bag. just a MESS.
Posted 3 years ago by michelle w.
HORRIBLE experience today. They first tried to wear out "it's a holiday weekend excuse" which got old the 3rd time I had to call them. I ordered at 11:54 and got my food at 1:43. When it finally arrived, it was food I wouldn't serve to my worst enemies let alone the fact they brought me chicken strips and cold wet, soggy oily fries. I do not eat meat. I ordered the fish and chips. How does this happen and WHERE does the communication break down when they READ MY ORDER IN WRITING???? They were rude and unapologetic. BEWARE AND DO NOT ORDER A-N-Y-T-H-I-N-G from this place!!!!
Posted 3 years ago by Erik L.
This place is quick, simple and has great quality food!
Posted 3 years ago by Jason K.
UNBELIEVABLE! I must be a fool because I've order ONE bagel from them multiple times and YET to get it right. When will downtown get a good bagel place?! This is not rocket science
Posted 3 years ago by Abby B.
Horrible service! Placed an order for a chicken wrap and coffee at 5:56pm, did not receive it until 7:12pm. Coffee was in the same bag as my wrap, it spilled all over the bag and when I picked the wrap up out of the bag, coffee poured out of the wrap foil. On top of ALL of that, the coffee was ice cold. VERY disappointing.
Posted 3 years ago by Amber W.
I've ordered from them several times and always had a good experience. They've never messed up my order and it always comes ahead of the scheduled time.
Posted 3 years ago by Jamie S.
Not good. Ordered bagels and cream cheese. They forgot the cream cheese so I asked the delivery guy to bring it. Got a call from Everything Bagels- apparently they didn't charge me for it so they wouldnt bring the cream cheese unless I paid in cash.
Posted 3 years ago by sara l.
TERRIBLE. The people are extremely rude. They do not want to do their job and are completely lazy. Do not dare give them your money they are awful.
Posted 3 years ago by Kerry P.
2 hours to get a bagel...
Posted 3 years ago by Erik O.
Good food at a great price, but they do mess up your order often, but even the mistakes are yummy
Posted 3 years ago by Monica M.
Not good. I live on St. Marks. I recently tried this place and the food was subpar. The lox I got on my bagel was all sinewy and hard to chew. The bagels were definitely not fresh at 9am on a Saturday. We ordered them toasted and they weren't. My house is like three blocks away and I waited like 45 minutes for two bagels and two coffees and two fresh squeezed OJs. AND the whole thing cost $30. Never again.
Posted 3 years ago by Benjamin S.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Everything Bagels Cafe's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Everything Bagels Cafe by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.